Can Virginia Give Its Electoral Votes to Someone Virginians Didn’t Choose?

Constitutional Showdown by Jeff Bayard

ATTENTION: Major social media outlets are finding ways to block the conservative/evangelical viewpoint. Click here for daily electronic delivery of the day's top blogs from Virginia Christian Alliance.

CONSTITUTIONAL SHOWDOWN · YOUR VOTE
Reading the text as written and testing every claim of power against it, so believers can practice faithful, clear-eyed citizenship.

Virginia has joined the National Popular Vote compact. If enough states follow, Virginia’s 13 electoral votes would go to the national winner, even in a year when that candidate does not win Virginia.

Ruth taught fifth grade in Lynchburg for thirty-one years. She has voted in every presidential election since 1972. She reads the sample ballot at her kitchen table, and she never misses.

Here is what Ruth may not know. In April, Virginia signed on to a pact with other states. If enough states join, Virginia’s electoral votes would no longer go to the candidate who wins Virginia. They would go to whoever wins the most votes across the whole country.

Ruth’s ballot would still be counted. But its job would change. It would help choose the national winner, instead of deciding where Virginia’s electoral votes go.

Hold onto two words: state and nation. The Constitution lets each state decide how to choose its presidential electors. The question is whether states can band together to hand that choice to a national count, without changing the Constitution.

We want to hear from you. If we got a fact wrong, tell us in the comments. If you see it differently, tell us that too.

What the National Popular Vote Compact Does

The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact is an agreement among states. Each member promises to give all its electoral votes to the candidate who wins the national popular vote.

There is a catch. The compact only switches on when its members hold a majority of the Electoral College, which today means at least 270 of 538 votes. Until then, nothing changes.

As of November 16, 2026, 18 states and the District of Columbia have enacted the compact. Together they hold 222 electoral votes, 48 short of 270. Virginia joined on April 13, 2026, when Gov. Abigail Spanberger signed HB 965 and its companion, SB 322.

In November’s elections, Democrats won control of the governor’s office and both legislative chambers in Michigan, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, and Nevada for the coming terms. Those states hold 50 electoral votes, enough to bring the compact to 272 if all four join. Supporters see a possible path to activating it for 2028, though more states would have to act in time.

The attorney general has announced his opposition. Attorney General Todd Blanche appeared on Fox News’ Life, Liberty & Levin on November 15. According to published reports of the interview, he said the administration would challenge the compact: “we will take it to the Supreme Court if we have to, because this would be a blatant violation of the Constitution.” No court has ruled on the compact.

A Real Example: 2024

This isn’t just theory. Consider the last election.

In 2024, the Democratic nominee won Virginia. Nationwide, the Republican nominee won the most votes. Apply the compact’s rule to those actual totals, and Virginia would have appointed 13 electors pledged to the candidate who did not win Virginia. Of course, a different rule might have changed how candidates campaigned and how people voted. But the example shows how the rule works.

The same thing could happen in reverse in another year. The rule does not name a party or guarantee victory to either one. In any given election, it could help either party’s nominee. That is why this is a constitutional question, not a partisan one.

Scripture shows that how a people chooses its leaders matters. When Moses organized Israel, he said, “Choose for your tribes wise, understanding, and experienced men, and I will appoint them as your heads” (Deuteronomy 1:13). That passage doesn’t prescribe an Electoral College. But it shows God’s people choosing qualified leaders through their own communities, tribe by tribe.


We would appreciate your donation.

What the Constitution Says About Electors

Americans don’t vote for President directly. We vote for electors, who then cast the votes that count. Article II, Section 1 says each state shall appoint electors “in such Manner as the Legislature thereof may direct.”

Notice who decides: each state’s legislature. The Supreme Court has upheld broad state power here. In McPherson v. Blacker (1892), it upheld Michigan’s choice to pick electors by district. In Chiafalo v. Washington (2020), it upheld a state law requiring electors to keep their pledges. Neither case ruled on this compact.

The Constitution assigns each state a number of electors based on its seats in Congress. It does not require states to use today’s winner-take-all method. Alexander Hamilton defended the design in Federalist 68: “if the manner of it be not perfect, it is at least excellent.”

The Clause the Compact Must Clear

But there is a second clause. Article I, Section 10 says: “No State shall, without the Consent of Congress, … enter into any Agreement or Compact with another State.”

That is the Compact Clause. Whether this compact needs Congress’s consent is disputed.

Not every agreement between states needs consent. In Virginia v. Tennessee (1893), the Court said the clause aims at agreements “tending to the increase of political power in the states, which may encroach upon or interfere with the just supremacy of the United States.” In U.S. Steel Corp. v. Multistate Tax Commission (1978), the Court applied that test again and upheld a tax compact without Congress’s consent.

So one central question is this: does the compact increase state power in a way that interferes with the federal system? Other objections could remain even if Congress approved it.

The Strongest Case for the Compact

Supporters start with Article II. Each state already decides how to award its electors. Most states give all their votes to the statewide winner. Maine and Nebraska give one electoral vote to the winner of each congressional district and two to the statewide winner. If a state may choose winner-take-all, supporters ask, why can’t it choose the national winner?

On the Compact Clause, supporters argue that the compact changes state laws, not the Constitution. Appointing electors is a state power. So, they say, the agreement does not invade federal power and needs no consent from Congress.

They also point to history. In five elections, 1824, 1876, 1888, 2000, and 2016, the winner did not lead the national popular vote. Gov. Spanberger put it this way to WSET: “Depending on the state you live in, your vote does count differently.” Supporters say the compact makes every American’s vote count equally, no matter the state.

The Strongest Case Against the Compact

Opponents say the compact changes how America picks a President without amending the Constitution. Hans von Spakovsky, an election law expert, argued: “They can’t use a compact to, in essence, change the Electoral College.”

They argue the compact is exactly the kind of agreement the Compact Clause was written to check. Once members hold an electoral majority, their electors would be pledged to the national winner. Critics say that weakens the role of each state’s separate result, the very thing the Electoral College was built on.

And they point to Virginia’s own voters. Rep. John McGuire wrote, “Virginia voters have a right to decide who they want representing them in the White House.”

What the New Congress Means for Ruth’s Vote

Democrats won control of both chambers of the next Congress. Compact supporters may ask it for approval.

Would that settle it? Not entirely. In Cuyler v. Adams (1981), the Court said Congress’s consent turns a compact into federal law when its subject is one Congress may legislate on. The Court has never applied that to this compact.

Congress usually approves compacts by passing a bill, which goes to the President, who can veto it. Whether the President must sign every kind of consent is disputed. In the Senate, opponents could filibuster, and ending debate generally takes 60 votes.

Even with Congress’s approval, opponents would still go to court. And Congress cannot supply the missing votes. States holding at least 48 more electoral votes would still have to enact the compact themselves.

The Third Way: Decide It by the Constitution

Both sides have real arguments. Article II gives states wide power. The Compact Clause limits what states may do together. Honest people disagree about where the line falls, and the courts may have to draw it.

The Constitution also offers a direct route for anyone who wants a national popular vote. Congress can propose an amendment by a two-thirds vote in each house, and three-fourths of the states must ratify it. Article V also allows a convention called by two-thirds of the state legislatures. That path is hard on purpose. The Framers wanted changes to the system itself to have broad agreement across the states.

Scripture speaks to how we carry ourselves in a fight like this. “Do not move the ancient landmark that your fathers have set” (Proverbs 22:28). Proverbs forbids moving a neighbor’s boundary marker. It doesn’t make any election system sacred. But it does teach respect for lawful boundaries. And Jeremiah called God’s people to “ask for the ancient paths, where the good way is; and walk in it, and find rest for your souls” (Jeremiah 6:16). That call governs our conduct here: honest argument, lawful means, and respect for neighbors who disagree.

The Third Way answer, then, is not “keep it” or “scrap it.” It is “decide it by the Constitution.” If the nation wants a national popular vote, the surest path is the one where every state has a voice.

What the Citizen Does

Three Questions About Your Electoral Vote: Keep This
  1. Who sets the method? Your state legislature has broad power under Article II, within the Constitution’s other limits.
  2. When does a compact need Congress’s consent? When it increases state power in a way that may interfere with federal supremacy (Virginia v. Tennessee).
  3. Would Congress’s consent settle everything? No. Congress cannot approve a violation of another part of the Constitution.

Read it yourself: Article II · Article I, Section 10 · Federalist 68

Make one two-minute call. Call your state delegate and state senator. Say: “I’m a constituent. Where do you stand on Virginia’s membership in the National Popular Vote compact, and should Congress vote on it?” Find your legislators at Who’s My Legislator.

Pray for those in authority. Paul urged prayer “for kings and all who are in high positions, that we may lead a peaceful and quiet life, godly and dignified in every way” (1 Timothy 2:1–2). Pray for leaders of both parties, whether we agree with them or not: Virginia’s governor and General Assembly, Congress, and the courts that may decide this.

Keep learning. We’ve covered Virginia’s election fights before: the redistricting battle, Louisiana v. Callais and Virginia’s maps, and proof of citizenship to vote.

No election system can give us new hearts. Only the Spirit of God can. But the God who gave Israel wise men from every tribe can still raise up wise and just leaders, in Richmond and in Washington.

Sources

Unless otherwise noted, Scripture quotations are from the English Standard Version (ESV).

The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Virginia Christian Alliance.

Scripture Quotations

Bible translations are identified by abbreviation with each Scripture reference.

Scripture quotations marked KJV are from the King James Version, which is in the public domain in the United States.

Scripture quotations marked ESV are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), copyright © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

Scripture quotations from other copyrighted Bible translations are identified by abbreviation and used in accordance with the respective publishers’ copyright and permissions requirements.

About the Author

Jeff Bayard
Devoted Christian, husband of 45 years, proud father of two grown children, and grandfather of three. As the diligent content manager and composer at the Virginia Christian Alliance, I curate and create articles that champion biblical values, uphold conservative principles, and honor the enduring truths of the Constitution. With a commitment to integrity and a heart for truth, I strive to ensure that our content informs, inspires, and resonates with readers who seek to glorify God in every aspect of life.

Comment Policy – Virginia Christian Alliance

We welcome thoughtful and respectful dialogue from all viewpoints. Comments must remain civil, relevant, and free of profanity, personal attacks, or mockery of Christian faith. Disagreement is allowed—disrespect is not.

Comments violating these standards may be edited or removed at our discretion.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted