Virginia Abortion Amendment: A Watchman's Plea to the Pews

What November Will Write Into Virginia’s Bill of Rights — and Why Your Pastor Needs to Hear It From You

By Jeff Bayard, Content Manager, Virginia Christian Alliance

Dear Christian, I am not writing to pastors today. I am writing to you.

Before you read another word, look up. Look at the child at the top of this page. That is an accurate medical visualization of a baby in the third trimester — not yet born, curled and whole, and the most helpless human being alive. He cannot vote. He cannot march. He cannot so much as speak his own name. Yet God commands us to speak for him: “Open your mouth for the mute, for the rights of all who are destitute” (Proverbs 31:8). And God has already settled what no ballot can un-settle — that this child is an image-bearer, knit by His own hand, and that his life is sacred because it is God’s alone to give.

Now look at the sword. It is no longer on the horizon. It is in plain sight — the Virginia abortion amendment, on this November’s ballot, raised over the wall that guards that child’s life. And the clock will not stop the second hand from ticking. November 3 is coming whether the church is awake or asleep.

I already wrote to the watchmen — one shepherd to another — in “A Warning to the Watchmen.” This letter is different. This one is for the man and the woman in the pew. Because the trumpet that must sound this November may never sound at all, unless you are the one who places it in your pastor’s hand.

That day, Virginians will vote to rewrite our Commonwealth’s Bill of Rights. One of those amendments would write a sweeping right to abortion into our highest law — permanently. And here is the hard truth I must tell you plainly: your pastor may never mention it. Not because he does not care. Because he is buried, and because the word “politics” makes him flinch. You can be the reason he picks up the trumpet anyway.

You Are Not Too Small for This

Most believers assume the current only runs one way — the pastor leads, the congregation follows. That is true, and it is good. But it is not the whole picture. The body of Christ was never designed to move in one direction only.

“Bear one another’s burdens, and so fulfill the law of Christ,” Paul writes in Galatians 6:2. Notice what he does not say. He does not say the pastor bears the burdens and the people receive. He says one another. The shepherd carries the flock — but Scripture also hands the flock a share in carrying him.

And your pastor is carrying a great deal. Hospital rooms at midnight. Marriages coming apart. A budget that will not stretch. A hundred quiet crises you never see. Into that weight, many pastors will not add what they fear is a partisan fight. So the sword keeps advancing, and no one blows the trumpet — not because the shepherd is faithless, but because no one in the pew ever brought him the burden and asked him to carry it with them.

A Burden Shared Is a Life Changed

Let me tell you why I believe this so strongly. It is not theory to me.

Years ago, in 2020, I was in serious pain with my neck, on a road that likely ended in surgery on my spine. I mentioned it — almost in passing — to a Christian sister. She did not shrug. She steered me to a man in Charlottesville who knew exactly what to do, and I was spared the operation entirely. God used one believer, paying attention, to change the course of my body.

That is Galatians 6:2 with skin on it. A burden I could barely name, shared with someone who was listening, became a rescue. I did not need a sermon on burden-bearing. I needed a sister who saw.

Now hold that beside what is coming in November. If a Christian will do that for a neck, how much more for a child who cannot point to his own pain — and for a church about to sleep through the vote that decides his future?

Here Is the Look

People do not see because they do not look. That is the whole problem, and Scripture named it long ago.

“Rescue those who are being taken away to death; hold back those who are stumbling to the slaughter. If you say, ‘Behold, we did not know this,’ does not he who weighs the heart perceive it?” (Proverbs 24:11–12). Read it slowly. God anticipates our excuse — “we did not know” — and He does not accept it. Willful blindness is not innocence. The One who weighs the heart knows the difference between a man who could not see and a man who would not look.

Look again at the child at the top of this page. The humanity you see in him — the fingers, the face, the sleeping weight of a person — was every bit as present, in smaller form, from the earliest weeks.

Please Support the Virginia Christian Alliance Website and Community Center

We would appreciate your donation.

“For you formed my inward parts; you knitted me together in my mother’s womb” (Psalm 139:13). David does not describe a clump of tissue that later becomes valuable. He describes God at work — deliberate, personal, hands on the loom — from the very beginning. If God is the One knitting, then no legislature and no ballot can vote that life into something less than an image-bearer.

Look at the child. Then look at what we are being asked to do.

What the Virginia Abortion Amendment Actually Says

I want to be precise, because a warning is only as strong as the truth beneath it.

The abortion amendment would add Section 11-A to Article I of the Virginia Constitution — our Bill of Rights — declaring a fundamental right to reproductive freedom, including abortion. Any law that would limit it must survive strict scrutiny: the state must prove a compelling interest, achieved by the least restrictive means. That is the highest bar in American law, and very few protections for the unborn could clear it.

On the third trimester, the amendment lets the state regulate — but it forbids the state from ever prohibiting an abortion when, in the professional judgment of a single physician, it is needed to protect the life or the physical or mental health of the mother, or when that physician judges the child not viable. Today, Virginia law requires three physicians to make that call. This would reduce it to one. And those health exceptions carry no gestational ceiling.

I will own my conviction as conviction: I believe abortion is the taking of an image-bearer’s life, and I grieve it. That is my moral claim, and I hold it before God. But the legal facts above are not my opinion — they are the text, and you can read it yourself.

Here is what makes this different from an ordinary law. This is a constitutional amendment. It passed the General Assembly twice, in two sessions, exactly as the constitution requires. Once the people vote yes, no court can undo it — a state court cannot strike down the constitution for violating the constitution. There is no appeal, no morning-after ruling. November 3 is the last word, and it is meant to be permanent.

That is why silence now is not caution. It is surrender on a delay.

The Oldest Lie in the Garden

Now look again at the words the amendment chooses. Not “abortion” up front, but “reproductive freedom.” The bill titles itself a fundamental right to reproductive freedom, and it tucks the ending of a life into the same sentence as prenatal care, childbirth, and fertility care — the vocabulary of a nursery wrapped around the reality of a grave.

That distance between the gentle word and the grave thing is not sloppy drafting. It is the oldest tactic there is.

In the garden, the serpent did not announce death. He renamed it. “You will not surely die,” he told the woman — you will be “like God” (Genesis 3:4–5). He took the one forbidden, fatal thing and dressed it as freedom and enlightenment. Eve reached for what looked like liberty and closed her hand on death. The lie was not loud. It was soft, reasonable, kind-sounding — and that is precisely why it worked.

So when a law files the death of an image-bearer under “freedom” and “care,” I do not first see clever politics. I see an ancient pattern, and behind it the one Jesus called the father of lies. “For we do not wrestle against flesh and blood, but against… the spiritual forces of evil in the heavenly places” (Ephesians 6:12). Paul is not reaching for drama. He is telling us where the real battle is fought — and it is not against our neighbors who will vote yes. They are not the enemy. Many are sincere, and the deceiver has always preferred sincere people; a deceived heart is the whole aim of a deception. Every one of us believed a lie once. The adversary behind the soft words is the same one who has been renaming death since Eden.

Once you see that, two things change. You stop being surprised. And you stop being afraid — because the outcome of this war was settled outside an empty tomb, and the Victor has already spoken.

“But That’s Politics”

I know the objection, because I have felt it too. “I don’t want my church dragged into politics.”

But hear me: the Bible is the most political book in human history — not because it endorses a party, but because it tells people how to live. Every command about life, marriage, justice, and mercy is a claim on how a society orders itself. When Scripture says God knits a child in the womb, that is not a private devotional thought. It is a public truth with a vote attached to it this November.

Our Editorial Board cleared this ground in “The Word the Enemy Stole,” and I laid it out plainly in “Christians and Politics: Please Take a Stand.” The short version is this: a Christian’s vote on whether to write a right to end an image-bearer’s life into our Bill of Rights is not partisanship. It is stewardship. This is no longer about left and right — it is about a wall God built, proposed for demolition by public vote.

Let Me Be Fair

I owe the other side an honest hearing, and so do you.

Those championing this amendment will tell you they are protecting women in genuine medical crisis — mothers facing a nightmare diagnosis, families in tragedy who do not want the government in the room. Many of them believe this with their whole hearts, and the fear behind it is not imaginary. That concern is real, and we cheapen ourselves if we pretend otherwise.

But the amendment writes far more than emergency care into permanent constitutional law. It installs a fundamental right, guarded by the highest legal standard we have, with no gestational limit on a single doctor’s judgment — and it places the whole question beyond the reach of any future correction. Grant every ounce of the sincerity. The question remains: does a right to end the life of an image-bearer belong in a Bill of Rights?

Go to Your Pastor — With Honor

So here is what I am asking you to do. Not to argue. To help.

Go to your pastor the way Scripture says to: “Obey your leaders and submit to them, for they are keeping watch over your souls, as those who will have to give an account” (Hebrews 13:17). Notice — he is a watchman too, and one who will answer to God for your soul. You do not march into his office to accuse him. You come as one who honors his watch and wants to strengthen it.

And do not be afraid. You are not starting a fight; you are stepping into one that has raged since Eden — on the side that has already won. “God gave us a spirit not of fear but of power and love and self-control” (2 Timothy 1:7). If the real adversary is the deceiver behind the soft words, then an honest, humble conversation with your own shepherd is the last thing on earth you need to fear.

Bring him the burden the way that sister brought me help. Hand him “A Warning to the Watchmen (pdf).” Hand him this letter. Ask him, gently, to make this not one Sunday but a season — from the pulpit, in the bulletin, in the announcements, until the last ballot is cast. And ask him the one question that matters: will he blow the trumpet, or keep it in the closet?

Then do your own part. See that you are registered. See that you show up on November 3. A watchman who warns and then stays home has only rehearsed.

The Line Still Hangs

I will not predict defeat, and I refuse to despair. Despair is simply disobedience wearing a humble face.

No argument on this page will change a single heart. Only the Spirit who raised Christ from the dead can do that. But the same God who knits the image-bearer in the womb can still wake a sleeping church — and He often does it through one ordinary believer who paid attention. A sister once did that for my neck. You may be the one who does it for your congregation, and for the children who cannot speak for themselves.

Look at the child. Bring the burden to your shepherd. And leave the outcome in the hands of the One who has never lost a battle in the history of the world.